News

Doubt over the value of HPV jab for teenagers

09-Feb-07

Vaccinating teens against HPV will not be cost-effective and could divert resources away from the current cervical screening programme, a public health expert has warned.

The first vaccine against HPV, patented as Gardasil, has received its European licence but the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation’s HPV subgroup has still to decide whether vaccinating all girls, and perhaps boys, from the age of 11 is to be recommended. 

Dr Angela Raffle, public health lead for cervical screening at Bristol PCT, is concerned that giving the vaccine to UK teenagers will more than double the cost of the current cervical cancer control programme ‘for little or no gain’.

But national roll-out of a HPV vaccine was defended by Dr Sarah Jarvis, RCGP women’s health spokeswoman.

‘I would anticipate this is one of the most cost-effective vaccinations in UK history, given the savings in terms of colposcopy and genital wart treatment,’ she said.

Comments

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

Login to comment


forgotten your password?

Quick search - use * for an abbreviated search, eg nico*

 
 

Healthcare Republic Forums

 

Registrar

RCGP Curriculum - 15.8 Respiratory Problems

This section of our curriculum guide refers to statement 15.8, Respiratory Problems, produced by the... Read more

RCGP Curriculum - 15.10 Skin Problems

This section of our curriculum guide refers to statement 15.10, Skin Problems, produced by the Royal... Read more

RCGP Curriculum - 15.6 Metabolic Problems

This section of our curriculum guide refers to statement 15.6, Metabolic Problems, produced by the R... Read more

Show all articles

 

Latest Clinical Articles

Chronic constipation

Contributed by Dr Naila Arebi, consultant gastroenterologist, St Mark's Hospital, Harrow, and The Lo... Read more

Sexually transmitted infections

Contributed by Dr Alan McOwan, lead clinician, Victoria Clinic for HIV and Sexual Health, London. Read more

Pemphigus

Contributed by Dr Sacha Goolamali, dermatology specialist registrar and Dr Rachael Morris-Jones, con... Read more

Show all clinical articles

MIMS Product News

New drug - NuvaRing

A non-daily, low oestrogen contraceptive utilising a vaginal delivery system. Read more

New drug - Siklos

Nordic Pharma has launched Siklos (hydroxycarbamide) for the prevention of recurrent painful vaso-oc... Read more

New drug - Bridion

Schering-Plough has launched Bridion (sugammadex) for the reversal of neuromuscular blockade induced... Read more

Jobs

 

Job of the Week