News

LMCs condemn NHS24 as 'waste of resources'

29-Apr-08

Scottish LMCs said that NHS 24 is a 'huge waste of resources' but stopped short of calling for a return to a GP-managed delivery of out-of-hours care.

Dr Kathryn McLachlan, of Greater Glasgow and Clyde LMC, told the Clydebank conference last week that NHS 24 was risk averse and disliked by the ambulance service, A&E departments, GPs and many patients.

Dr McLachlan said it was also the main reason why out-of-hours care gets a bad press. 

‘Out of hours is blamed on us for turning our backs on our patients,' she said.

Dr McLachlan said there should be a negotiated return of out of hours with attached resources to locally based GP-managed delivery. 

‘We need a system that listens to those of us who see patients. Maybe we should go back to co-ops.  Maybe we should be doing this again,' she said.

But Daniel Franks of Tayside LMC said the suggestion made him nervous. 

‘If we take this over then they will cut the funding year on year, exactly as they're doing at the moment,' he said.

The motion was rejected, but GPs passed others that supported doctor-involvement NHS 24. 

They agreed with a motion that said that NHS 24 works best when co-located with out-of-hours services run by experienced doctors. 

Dr McLachlan said that NHS24 was too costly at £50m per year and £30 per call answered.

GPletters@haymarket.com

Read all the latest news from the Scottish LMCs conference

Comment below and tell us what you think 

Comments

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

Login to comment


forgotten your password?

Quick search - use * for an abbreviated search, eg nico*

 
 

Healthcare Republic Forums

 

Registrar

Golden rules for registrars

Medico-legal adviser Dr Jim Rodger offers some expert advice on how to excel as a GP registrar. Read more

Career paths - Working abroad in a rural practice

Dr Kingsley Poole describes the differences he experienced working at a remote practice in New Zeala... Read more

Professional development - Honing your presentation skills

Most people feel nervous facing an audience, but practice will make it easier, says Dr Kevin Brown. Read more

Show all articles

 

Latest Clinical Articles

Clinical Review - Malaria

Contributed by Dr Charlie Easmon specialist adviser in travel medicine and medical director at The N... Read more

Clinical Review - Renal colic

Contributed by Mr Ranan DasGupta, specialist registrar and Mr Jonathon Olsburgh, consultant urologic... Read more

Clinical Review - Stroke

By Dr Helen Hosker, GP and clinical commissioning lead for stroke, NHS Manchester, and Dr Pippa Tyrr... Read more

Show all clinical articles

MIMS Product News

New drug - Xamiol

Leo Pharma has launched Xamiol gel, a combination of calcipotriol + betamethasone, for the treatment... Read more

New drug - Xarelto

Bayer HealthCare has launched Xarelto (rivaroxaban) for the prevention of venous thromboembolism in ... Read more

New drug - Torisel

Wyeth has launched Torisel (temsirolimus), a first-line treatment for advanced renal cell carcinoma ... Read more

Jobs

 

Job of the Week