News

GPs refuse to pilot summary care records

07-May-08

A 'significant minority' of GPs are refusing to participate in the summary care record (SCR) programme, say researchers.

A report out this week from University College London found that at least two practices have pulled out of the programme because of ethical concerns about the system of assumed consent.

The electronic record programme allows hospital doctors to access a patient's GP records and medical history. It is currently being trialled in a number of ‘early adopter' areas before being rolled out nationally. 

The researchers found that it offered real benefits for treating patients in emergencies. However, some GPs see it as incompatible with their role in protecting patient confidentiality.

The report found that many patients were not aware of the SCR programme, raising questions about whether consent could be assumed. It proposed shifting to a system under which NHS staff must ask a patient for their consent whenever they wish to look at their records. 

Dame Deidre Hine, chairman of the BMA working party on IT, welcomed the report's recommendations. ‘We would strongly urge that until these changes are made there should be no further roll out of the scheme,' she added.

jonn.elledge@haymarket.com

Comment below and tell us what you think 


Comments

Graham Brown

07/05/2008

This is another example of mass scale assumed consent, which is dangerous and probably infringes several pieces of legislation. Add to this automatic opt-in for Electronic Px's, organ donation and the national spine.

Mary Hawking

08/05/2008

 There is a right of refusal to have a SRC - and patients in the pilots were supposed to be informed of the SCR and their options explained.

When a practice moves to a system which is planned to be shared with organisations outside the practice (a Single Shared EPR - SSEPR - such as CSC/TPP SystmOne and Lorenzo level 4) is installed, what are the mechanisms for informing the patients affected, and is it possible to have patient optout - whether of having a shared record or of allowing access - in a SSEPR or Detailed Care Record when that DCR is a SSEPR - the Lorenzo model? 

Hyman Silver

09/05/2008

Dates given on messages now seem to have adopted the American system - Why? It is confusing.

Why can we not continue to use the British system- is the American superior or is it that we have to copy everything they do ?

Emilie Reymond

12/05/2008

 You can change your time settings in the Edit Profile section above.

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

Login to comment


forgotten your password?

Healthcare Republic Forums

 

Registrar

How to apply for your certificate

Applying to the RCGP for your CCT recommendation now takes three clicks, writes Fiona Erasmus. Read more

A question of capacity

Medicolegal advisor, Dr John Holden addresses some dilemmas on consent that may be faced by GPs. Read more

Workplace-based assessment

The WPBA should be seen as a developmental process, says the RCGP's Dr Jane Mamelok. Read more

Show all articles

 

Latest Clinical Articles

Endometriosis

Contributed by Mr Michael Booker, consultant obstetrician & gynaecologist, and fertility specialist ... Read more

Primary hyperparathyroidism

Contributed by Mr David Scott-Coombes, consultant endocrine surgeon at the University Hospital of Wa... Read more

Clinical Review - Headache in children

Contributed by Dr David Kernick, a GPSI in headache, based in Exeter. Read more

Show all clinical articles

MIMS Product News

Toviaz

New drug - Toviaz

Pfizer has launched Toviaz (fesoterodine), a once-daily treatment for the symptoms of overactive bla... Read more

New drug - Tasigna

Novartis has launched Tasigna (nilotinib), a new antineoplastic agent for Philadelphia chromosome po... Read more

Ciproxin licensed for UTI in children

The licence for Ciproxin (ciprofloxacin) has been extended to include the second- and third-line tr... Read more

Jobs

 

Job of the Week